Wednesday, June 16, 2021

Review: Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir

Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir
View on amazon

TL;DR Interstellar mission to save all life on earth. Very readable hard science fiction. Buy this book and read it, it's excellent

Andy Weir writes the most entertaining hard, hard science, science fiction that I've ever read. Even Artemis, set on the moon and which has much less hard science, does a good job with the technical details to give the reader a feel for what living on the moon would be like.

If you read The Martian, the book that launched Andy and made him synonymous with hard science fiction, you'll recognize the protagonist, Ryland Grace: a scientist, very good at improvising, who finds himself at the core of a life or death situation. This time it's not just one person's life at stake, it's the survival of every living thing on earth. 

Warning: I'm not sensitive to spoilers so read at own risk.

Ryland is happily teaching middle school science when he is conscripted to study organic. particles (later dubbed astrophages)  retrieved from a mysterious line that stretches from the sun to Venus, the Petrova Line. Ryland is selected because he was a molecular biologist who once wrote a paper asserting that water isn't necessary to life. The reaction to his paper drove him out of science but it shows that he can think outside of conventional science. The Petrova Line is draining energy from the sun and at the rate it's occurring, life on earth is doomed. Ryland makes significant discoveries and soon becomes the right hand man to Eva Stratt who has been given absolute authority to save the earth. And I mean absolute, the woman can take over a Chinese aircraft carrier.

Most of the science will be over readers' heads but the fun is watching the process, how the science is done. Being first person, we get get Ryland talking himself through experiments as he tries to figure out how to understand this very weird life forms.

The earth part of the story shows why we would need a dictator with absolute power to accomplish what needs to be done. If even a small part of the population is to survive, decisions have to be made that go against everything people believe.  I won't spoil a "holy crap, they're going to do that!" moment but it is jaw dropping. Decisions have to be made and there is no time to argue and form committees.

Astronomers start exploring the universe to see if other Pertova Lines exist and they discover that Tau Ceti has such a line but the sun there isn't diminishing. Why is that sun coping but our sun isn't? Scientists have discover how to harness the enormous power in the astrophages and the decision is made to send a crew of three, in induced comas, on a one-way trip to Tau Ceti. There is just enough time to reach Tau Ceti, investigate, find a solution, and send three probes back to earth. I think readers will be amused at how they decide to make sure that the crew has all the information they need. 

Unfortunately, a catastrophic accident leaves Ryland the only qualified scientist to join the expedition. He has to be forced to "volunteer". I liked this bit. Ryland isn't a noble hero willing to sacrifice his life for all humankind but somewhat of a coward.

When he awakens, he discovers that his companions, the pilot and the engineer, have died on the trip. But being an inquisitive scientist, throws himself into mission. Complicating things is that there wasn't time to train him in ship operations so he has to train himself to pilot a space craft. Readers who suffer from innumeracy beware, there is lots of math as Ryland figures out the capabilities of the ship and how to navigate.

As Ryland maneuvers the Hail Mary into position, he discovers he isn't alone, he finds an alien spacecraft. First contact is made and this may be my favorite part of the story as they progress from "where are you from" using models to a partnership to save their worlds. The alien, who Ryland names Rocky, has advanced engineering abilities and figures how to link the ships. The process by which they find a way to communicate and overcome the problem that Ryland's and Rocky's environments are hostile to the other is fascinating. The author does a wonderful job describing an alien that seems very plausible. It's also funny at time especially when Rocky learns sarcasm.

The math and science are above my head but, as on earth, it is very engrossing to watch as Ryland and Rocky reason their way through obstacles.

Weir has the remarkable skill to deliver very detailed science without it being an infodump. He really brings science to life.  I was totally invested in the characters and the story and read it in two sittings. 

Project Hail Mary is a terrific read and might be my favorite SF story since The Martian. There are a few things that I wished had been touched upon. If I have one criticism, it's that the ending is a bit twee for me.

Andy Weir writes the most entertaining hard, hard science, science fiction that I've ever read. Even Artemis, set on the moon, which has much less hard science, does a good job with the technical details to give the reader a feel for what living on the moon would be like.

If you read The Martian, the book that launched Andy and made him synonymous with hard science fiction, you'll recognize the protagonist, Ryland Grace: a scientist, very good at improvising, who finds himself at the core of a life or death situation. This time it's not just one person's life at stake, it's the survival of every living thing on earth. 

Warning: I'm not sensitive to spoilers so read at own risk.

Ryland is happily teaching middle school science when he is conscripted to study organic. particles (later dubbed astrophages)  retrieved from a mysterious line that stretches from the sun to Venus, the Petrova Line. Ryland is selected because he was a molecular biologist who once wrote a paper asserting that water isn't necessary to life. The reaction to his paper drove him out of science but it shows that he can think outside of conventional science. The Petrova Line is draining energy from the sun and at the rate it's occurring, life on earth is doomed. Ryland makes significant discoveries and soon becomes the right hand man to Eva Stratt who has been given absolute authority to save the earth. And I mean absolute, the woman can take over a Chinese aircraft carrier.

Most of the science will be over readers' heads but the fun is watching the process, how the science is done. Being first person, we get get Ryland talking himself through experiments as he tries to figure out how to understand this very weird life forms.

The earth part of the story shows why we would need a dictator with absolute power to accomplish what needs to be done. If even a small part of the population is to survive, decisions have to be made that go against everything people believe.  I won't spoil a "holy crap, they're going to do that!" moment but it is jaw dropping. Decisions have to be made and there is no time to argue and form committees.

Astronomers start exploring the universe to see if other Pertova Lines exist and they discover that Tau Ceti has such a line but the sun there isn't diminishing. Why is that sun coping but our sun isn't? Scientists have discover how to harness the enormous power in the astrophages and the decision is made to send a crew of three, in induced comas, on a one-way trip to Tau Ceti on earth's first instellar craft, the Hail Mary. There is just enough time to reach Tau Ceti, investigate, find a solution, and send three probes back to earth. I think readers will be amused at how they decide to make sure that the crew has all the information they need. 

Unfortunately, a catastrophic accident leaves Ryland the only qualified scientist to join the expedition. He has to be forced to "volunteer". I liked this bit. Ryland isn't a noble hero willing to sacrifice his life for all humankind but somewhat of a coward.

When he awakens, he discovers that his companions, the pilot and the engineer, have died on the trip. But being an inquisitive scientist, throws himself into mission. Complicating things is that there wasn't time to train him in ship operations so he has to train himself to pilot a space craft. Readers who suffer from innumeracy beware, there is lots of math as Ryland figures out the capabilities of the ship and how to navigate.

As Ryland maneuvers the Hail Mary into position, he discovers he isn't alone, he finds an alien spacecraft. First contact is made and this may be my favorite part of the story as they progress from "where are you from" using models to a partnership to save their worlds. The alien, who Ryland names Rocky, has advanced engineering abilities and figures how to link the ships. The process by which they find a way to communicate and overcome the problem that Ryland's and Rocky's environments are hostile to the other is fascinating. The author does a wonderful job describing an alien that seems very plausible. It's also funny at time especially when Rocky learns sarcasm.

The math and science are above my head but, as on earth, it is very engrossing to watch as Ryland and Rocky reason their way through obstacles.

Weir has the remarkable skill to deliver very detailed science without it being an infodump. He really brings science to life.  I was totally invested in the characters and the story and read it in two sittings. 

Project Hail Mary is a terrific read and might be my favorite SF story since The Martian. There are a few things that I wished had been touched upon. If I have one criticism, it's that the ending is a bit twee for me.


Keywords: science fiction, interstellar travel, first contact, aliens, earth in peril

Friday, June 11, 2021

Mini Review: The Nikki Griffin Action Thrillers by S.A. Lelchuk

Actions thriller Save Me from Dangerous Men by S.A. Lelchuk
View on Amazon

 Save Me From Dangerous Men (2019) and One Got Away (2021) are pretty good action thrillers with enough danger, violence, and dead bodies to keep you reading deep into the night (personal experience). Blurbs compare Nikki to Jack Reacher and Lisbeth Salander but those are the obvious names to throw out to get people's attention. For me, Nikki is more like Robert Fates's character, Kristin Van Dijk, aka Baby Shark. Slight Detour: given the industry's love for female revenge films, I'm astounded that Baby Shark hasn't been turned into a movie.

Nikki is a private detective who also owns a used bookstore in Berkeley, Brimstone Magpie (a nod to Bleak House by Charles Dickens). While Nikki handles traditional PI work, her speciality is meting out what she calls proportional justice on men who hurt women and she's very good at convincing these men of the error of their ways.

I'm a retired librarian and a fun aspect of these book takes place in Nikki's bookstore when she is recommending books to customers. Nikki engages in what we in the library business call readers' advisory and I appreciate the [accurate] way the author works this into the story. 

Action thriller One Got Away by S.A. Lelchuk
View on Amazon

Warning: There may be spoilers ahead. I don't try to spare the reader.

There are a couple of things that annoy me a little that occur in these books. The biggie is the quirk the author gives Nikki: she refuses to carry a cell phone. She's a motorcycling riding private detective engaging in dangerous activities, tailing people, confronting people prone to violence, carrying out violent acts herself and she won't carry a phone! Any one of us can think of many scenarios where a cell phone would be essential. Besides the obvious calling for help or people calling her with warnings or information, there's access to maps and searching for people, places, and things. Instead, she has to borrow a phone when needed. Silly. I was equally annoyed by Lee Childe having Jack Reacher travel with just the clothes on his back and a tooth bush in his jacket pocket and no identification. Equally silly.

The author pulls out a trope I've really come to dislike intensely: a character says to the detective "I can't tell you now but meet me at 10 and I'll explain everything". Does anyone not know what's comes next? The author does avoid another trope where the detective puts important papers in a desk drawer and the office is later ransacked and the papers taken.

A miner quibble is when Nikki refers to semi-automatic pistol ammunition clips rather than using the correct word, magazines. At least firing a gun doesn't leave the smell of cordite.

Save Me From Dangerous Men

This is the first Nikki Griffin story so it is establishing her as a character, her environment, who she can call on for help in her PI work. Early on we learn about her aversion to cell phones. The main story has Nikki hired by a tech start-up to investigate an employee suspected of industrial espionage. Nikki figures out that neither the employee nor the company are what they seem and there is something much larger at stake, something that will have deadly results if not stopped. Along the way we see what Nikki considers proportional justice.

The big conspiracy plot didn't grab me overall though there are some nice investigative parts, deadly peril, grievous bodily harm, and Nikki adds to her body count. The way it wrapped up is a bit meh! for my tastes and I didn't think it likely to have resolved the way it did. 

This is a good character introduction. We get some back-story (traumatic event from childhood, drug addict brother), get to meet the love interest (an academic), meet Buster who runs a chop shop and has access to a three body trunk. And I really enjoy the scenes in Brimstone Magpie.

One Got Away

This second Nikki Griffin novel is much more to my liking. Her aversion to cell phones is still there but I am kind of making peace with it.

This time Nikki is hired by the son of the matriarch of an old money San Francisco [dysfunctional] family. The son fears that mom has fallen under the spell of a con man who is siphoning away family money. The con man is Dr. Geoffrey Coombs, Oxford educated doctor of psychology who is neither. Nikki soon discovers that Coombs' real education is how to avoid being caught. How Nikki tracks Coombs is very neatly done. She also learns that she is not the only one after Coombs and the case is a lot more complicated that she was briefed. Further complicating things is Nikki's growing respect for Coombs and the realization that they have a lot in common.

Buster returns in a bigger role, using his knowledge and contacts in the illegal automotive trade to assist Nikki. He is easily one of my favorite characters. Like Nikki, he doesn't mind breaking bones or putting a bullet in someone who needs it. Rough justice.

I swear the main villain is channelling The Fat Man from The Maltese Falcon. When he speaks I can hear Sidney Greenstreet's elaborate diction. This isn't a criticism, I thought it great fun. It gave me a visual image of the character though in black and white.

We do get the trope where the detective is fired but keeps on working because that's what detectives walking the mean streets do. Hey, it works for Philip Marlowe.

More action, more violence, a high body count, cool investigative techniques, delivering proportional justice, a human trafficking subplot (resolved), and a nice twisty ending make this a good action thriller. 

Save Me From Dangerous Men and One Got Away are an excellent start to a series and make me anticipate the next one.

Finally, go get a copy of Robert Fate's Baby Shark. I think you'll agree that Nikki and Kristin are sisters.



Keywords: action thriller, crime fiction, private detectives, female hero

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.